When comparing printing methods, the discussion of digital print vs screen print is a common one. Whether shopping for personalized tees, promotional items, or packaging services, selecting either can be difficult. Both have unique benefits, but they’re only ideal for certain kinds of work. This article will outline the main contrasts, procedures, prices, and things to consider to determine the best for you.
-
Primera LX600 Color Label Printer SKU: LX600$1,995.00
FREE SHIPPING over $199*
Orders before 12PM EST usually Ship Same Business Day - Epson C4000 / CW-C4000 ColorWorks Inkjet Label Printer (Gloss) SKU: C31CK03A9991$2,419.00
FREE SHIPPING over $199*
Orders before 12PM EST usually Ship Same Business Day -
Afinia CP950 Envelope Packaging and Box Color Label Printer SKU: 35256$19,995.00
FREE SHIPPING over $199*
Orders before 12PM EST usually Ship Same Business Day
Key Insights: Digital vs Screen Printing
Before diving deep into the screen printing vs digital printing comparison, let’s touch base briefly on why they are unique. Digital Printing is printing a digital image directly to a surface from digital files. By screen printing, layers of ink are deposited on a stencil (or screen) and then transferred onto the printing surface. These processes are suited to different needs and can impact your completed project’s quality, lifespan, and cost.
Exploring Screen Printing
Screen printing, professionally known as silk screening, has been used to produce fine-quality prints for decades. It is especially renowned for printing clothing, signs, and posters. Let’s look at the key points of screen printing.
The Process of Screen Printing
In the first step, a stencil or screen is created that contains the design to be printed. Screens are placed on materials and ink is pushed through them with a squeegee. The design is transferred onto the surface, one color at a time. If your design uses multiple colors, you need a separate screen for each one. The process requires precise setup and careful alignment to get everything just right.
Benefits of Screen Printing
- Durability: Screen prints are incredibly durable, especially when applied to fabric. By applying the ink directly to the material, vibrant results are achieved that won’t fade over time.
- Economical with Bulk Orders: Screen printing is economical and efficient when ordering identical print pieces in bulk. As the order size increases, the price will decrease per piece.
- Versatility: Screen printing can be done on various materials, such as cloth, metal, glass, and plastic, and can, therefore, be utilized on any product.
Understanding Digital Printing
Digital printing has gained popularity because it can print sharp designs straight from computer files to any substrate. Whether paper, fabrics, or ceramics, digital printing offers a speedy and accurate process.
The Process of Digital Printing
The digital printing process entails direct delivery of a digital file to the printer, from where it drops ink or toner onto the face of the material. There are no stencils or screens involved with digital printers like there are with screen printing, and instead, advanced technology is used to print full-color images with sharp clarity. The process is speedy when printing small orders.
Benefits of Digital Printing
- Sharp Prints: Since digital printing creates sharp and precise color images, it is excellent for designs with fine lines and gradients.
- No Setup Fee: Printing can begin immediately as neither stencils nor screens are involved. This implies neither setup fees nor ideal applications for small runs nor one-off prints.
- Rapid Turnaround: The reason digital printing is fast is a key benefit. Since there is no requirement for long setups, digital prints can be produced within minutes compared to their screen-printing counterpart.
However, digital printing is less durable than screen printing, can only be printed on some fabrics, and is less affordable for large orders.
Cost Comparison: Digital Printing vs Screen Printing
Understanding the cost differences between screen print vs digital print is essential for choosing the right method. Both are powerful but differ in initial setup fees and cost per print.
Setup Costs and Time Considerations
Screen Printing is generally costlier for setups because stencils and printing screens have to be made for it. If you buy large quantities of prints, you are spreading out the cost of setups over an enormous number of items, making it less expensive per unit to print using screens. However, when buying small orders, it can cost a huge amount upfront to set them all up.
Screen printing, however, requires a setup fee and screens. The price per unit is relatively lower for bulk orders than for digital printing, but it’s costlier for small quantities. Since no lengthy setup period is involved, digital printing can be quicker and more flexible.
Per-Print Pricing and Quantity
Digital printing is cheaper than printing small runs for limited runs. You pay per print individually because there is no initial setup, and it is perfect for printing one-off personalized work or limited edition runs.
However, screen printing becomes more cost-effective if you’re ordering in bulk. With ready-made screens, the price per print decreases with increasing quantity. This makes screen printing a better choice for large orders where uniformity is key.
Design Complexity and Detail Considerations
When considering screen printing vs digital printing, you must consider the simplicity or complexity of your design. Examine each process individually to determine what it offers the design process.
Detailed and Gradient Designs
If your design involves fine detail, intricate designs, or gradients, digital printing is the direction you want to take. This type of printing can print designs with much more clarity and fit all the details inside a high-definition framework.
Screen printing is limited when working with finely defined detail and gradation effects. While it can achieve dense areas of color with a very good effect, it may not print clear pictures when using complicated designs. For complicated designs, digital printing has a decided advantage.
Simple Designs and Large Quantities
The best screen printing designs are those with a limited color palette and simple graphic designs. This technique achieves full colors and sharp lines with little effort. The screen printing process is a great way to handle bulk orders with minimum fuss.
However, digital printing is relatively pricey when printing a large quantity of a limited number of designs because you’re paying for ink and paper. Screen printing is cheaper when you’re printing thousands with a simple design.
Digital Printing vs Screen Printing for Labels
Both digital print vs screen print methods are frequently used for label printing, but each has its advantages. A label printer can achieve high-quality reproductions for short productions, and whether to achieve digital print or screen print depends on the application.
- Digital printing is ideal for labels with hard-to-render details, gradients, or multicolored artwork. It’s also ideal for labels you’d like to print quickly in short runs, like for custom orders or seasonal items.
- Screen printing is the best option for orders requiring large quantities of simple designs. You can try screen printing for simple labels that require the same-quality labels in large quantities.
Material Compatibility and Durability
When choosing between screen printing vs digital printing, consider how each system handles different materials and how permanent and durable the print is in the long run. Both techniques work with materials to a certain extent and are durable to some extent, but with differences in application and outcomes.
Resistance to Weather and Surface Adhesion
One of the things that sets digital and screen printing apart is how well they resist weather and adhere to surfaces. This is particularly relevant to items that must resist rough environments, like signage or clothing worn in all types of weather.
The durability of screen printing makes it ideal for outdoor use. By using thicker inks, screen printing creates a strong, durable bond between the material and the ink. Prints made from these materials are extremely durable to fading, cracking, and weathering. For instance, a screen-printed t-shirt or outdoor banner can withstand sunlight, rain, and snow for longer without significant wear.
Conversely, digital printing is generally more susceptible to environmental stress. Digital printing inks are usually thinner, and although they are excellent at producing sharp, high-quality images, they are sometimes less durable. Weather resistance is a possible issue and can be a factor with fabrics. For instance, a digitally printed shirt might show signs of wear and fade after being washed frequently or left out in sunlight. The adhesion to a surface with digital printing is less durable than printing with screens, and it is eventually subject to chipping or peeling.
All things being equal, there is nothing like screen printing for long-term prints on products that will experience rough weather. Digital printing can still be done to great effect, but it is normally best done with products worn indoors or merchandise that will see minimal traffic and fresh air exposure.
Material Compatibility for Both Methods
Another factor to consider is how each type of printing works with various materials. Screen printing and digital printing are equally matched when working with materials, but being informed about those differences can allow you to make an informed decision based on your project.
Screen printing is extremely flexible regarding the materials it can work with. It can work with many substrates, including textiles, plastic materials, metals, and glass. This makes it ideal for printing promotional items, T-shirts, other apparel items, signs, signboards, and other tangible items. The heavy ink deposit left by screen printing sticks to virtually any substrate and works with rough and uneven substrates.
However, digital printing is less compatible with substrates than screen printing. As technology has progressed and digital printing has become increasingly capable, all kinds of substrates can now be digitally printed; however, it is less universal in its usage than screen printing. A paper substrate or vinyl substrate is a good choice for digital printing, as well as cardstock. There are possible printabilities with textile and certain plastic substrates, but print quality and durability can be inferior to those with screen printing.
Digital printing dominates label printing due to its ability to print intricate designs and bright colors. Nevertheless, it is still preferred for large runs of heavy-duty labels, especially when the label stock is stiffer or has a harder texture.
In short, screen printing is optimal for items requiring flexibility with diverse materials and stability with harsh elements. Digital printing is optimal with paper, vinyl, and apparel when incorporating intricate art with smaller orders.
Factors to Consider Before Choosing a Printing Method
Whether to choose screen vs digital printing is not solely decided by the item you’re printing or how permanent the print will be. The right solution depends on a number of factors, which should be taken into account when choosing a project. It is important to consider the following points:
Volume of Prints
Screen printing can be a better option for printing large orders. As we have already outlined above, the cost per unit is reduced with large runs when using screen printing technology. Once you have set up the screens, you can print hundreds and thousands of units within minutes, reducing the unit cost substantially.
However, digital printing is normally expensive for high runs since printing per unit is expensive, and you print separately per unit. While it is excellent for short runs or specialty print orders, it is expensive per print as you move to a large number.
Design Complexity
The intricacy of your design is a large factor in your choice. Should your design have subtle details, gradations, or several colors, digital printing is clearly the winner. This process is superior at printing intricate images with crisp clarity and is thus suited to designs difficult to replicate through screen printing.
However, it is best suited to simple designs with solid colors. If you have a plain logo or slogan to print, you can achieve heavy and bright prints through screen printing, and they will remain durable for a while.
Turnaround Time
If you’re short on time, digital printing has a clear advantage. There is minimal setup time involved, so digital duplicates can instantly be run off and are therefore ideal for rush runs or a single print run.
Screen printing is time-consuming. Setting up screens and aligning the design can take hours, sometimes two days, to accomplish. The setup time makes it slower when producing small orders.
Budget Constraints
Digital printing is less expensive for small quantities if you are short on budget. There is no setup fee and a smaller initial investment, and it is best suited for minimal orders. For large runs, it is less expensive to do it via screen printing, as the cost per unit decreases when the quantity is large.
Where Can I Get the Digital Printer?
You can obtain a digital printer from TCS Digital Solutions, a reputable provider specializing in digital label printers. Their digital printing solutions are diverse enough to meet the needs of any business. We are known for the high quality of our products, our reliable customer support, and our low prices at TCS Digital Solutions. Whether you require a digital printer for commercial or personal use, TCS Digital Solutions can assist you in finding the ideal solution. Furthermore, their team can help you determine the best option for you based on your requirements by providing guidance and expertise. Trust TCS Digital Solutions for your digital printing needs.
Final Takeaway
Digital printing vs screen printing is simply a matter of choosing among different factors, such as print run, simplicity of design, compatibility with materials, and need for durability. Screen printing is best suited to large orders, simple designs, and materials that need durability. Digital printing best suits intricate designs, short runs, and materials with high-detailing print requirements.
If you want to have it all, TCS Digital Solutions provides you with world-class digital printers capable of producing superior quality prints for any project you have. If you print labels, apparel, or promotional items, TCS Digital Solutions can help you determine the best printing process to meet your requirements.
Have any questions to ask regarding digital print vs screen print? Contact our support staff via email at orders@tcsdigitalsolutions.com or via a phone call at (678) 824-2304 or +1 (762) 208-6985. The TCS Digital Solutions Expert Support Staff is always there to support you. To learn about the Digital printer, click on our blogs and get answers to all your questions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Digital Printing Or Screen Printing Better?
It’s all about the project. Digital printing takes precedence for short runs, intricate designs, and quick turnarounds. Stick with screen printing for large orders, straightforward designs, and long-lasting items.
What Are The Best Uses For Digital Printing?
Digital printing is optimal for small runs, intricate designs, and short manufacturing lead times. It is best suited for personalized t-shirts, stickers, and short-pack runs.
How Does Digital Textile Printing Differ From Screen Printing?
Digital textile printing involves printing digital files directly onto fabric, while screen printing requires creating a stencil for each color. A digital textile printer is ideal for complex designs and small runs, while a screen printer is appropriate for large runs of simpler designs.
Why Is Digital Printing Generally More Expensive?
Digital printing is relatively costlier per print because it involves technology and ink. While it is optimal for a small-run print job, it becomes cost-prohibitive with quantity compared to screen printing.
How Do The Durability Aspects Of Screen Printing And Digital Printing Compare?
Screen printing offers longer durability for products to undergo weathering or heavy wear and tear. Digital printing is less durable and can fade earlier, especially for clothing or products that undergo rough circumstances.
Related Articles
